Part 2
- Back to the end of Season 3, which is a nice touch. Kate screeches to a halt, and that's not the only screeching she does. "We have to go back?!?" She berates Jack for his recent strange behavior, and reveals that "Jeremy Bentham" is the man in the coffin. Who the heck is that? Kate continues to screech. "I still have to explain to him [Aaron] why you're not there to read to him." It's been three years since they left the island, and that day brought horrible things. She closes her speech defiantly: "how dare you ask me to go back?" Clearly, that means they're going back.
- On the island, Ben and Evil Army Guy exchange pleasantries. Kate runs out of the jungle, guns are drawn, and things get crazy. The island's spooky whispers return, and with them the deadly Others. The real ones. Sayid and EAG have one of the greatest fights I've ever seen on TV, full of kicking and stabbing and fun with sticks, but it's Richard who shoots EAG in the back. Kate and Sayid worked out a deal to rescue Ben in exchange for their freedom. I demand more Richard in Season 5.
- Sawyer and Jack banter and bicker in the woods. They find Hurley, who is peeing. That's an odd choice - but you know, everyone wondered when Jack Bauer found time to pee, and you never saw it. I appreciate Lost taking the time to show that peeing is important. Jack and Locke are reunited, and I gotta tell you, it does NOT feel so good. They immediately begin sniping away, talking about leader stuff. "You're not supposed to go home... you're here for a reason," pleads Locke, and he asks Jack to lie about the island to protect its miracles. "It's an ISLAND, John.... there's no such thing as miracles," barks Jack. We know better. Then Ben shows up, and kicks Jack out, and Locke can't help but dig at Jack one last time before descending underground with Ben.
- Man, the Orchid is DEEP. Before too long, the station is lit and whirring with activity. Ben shoves an orientation video at Locke so that he'll be entertained - kind of like a parent would give a child a lollipop or a Nintendo DS. Meanwhile, Ben gathers every metallic object he can find. As for the video: Casimir Effect! Negatively charged exotic matter! Mysteeeeerious rewinding! In summation: "time traveling bunnies." Unfortunately, it looks like Ben and Locke will be interrupted before they can get hopping. (See what I did there?) EAG?!? Dammit Richard, that's why you shoot in the HEAD. EAG talks to himself for a while, explaining that he has a "dead man's trigger" on him, and it's connected to a whole lot of C4. If he dies, the freighter blows up. Oh, and don't forget, he killed Alex, so he's not f-ing around. Locke tries to talk it out, but Ben's doing his best Inigo Montoya impression - "you killed my daughter, prepare to die" - and then he kills everyone on the boat by stabbing EAG in the neck. Good times!
- So about that C4. "Boom," says Desmond. "Boom," repeats Jin. "Biiiiiig badda boom," says Electra. The men try to save the day with some liquid nitrogen and six months of explosives training. In the middle of neutralizing the C4, Sun blurts out to Michael that she's pregnant. It appears to affect Michael no more than an announcement that today's lunch is fish sticks. Well, he's distracted.
- Off in the future, a kindly old lady asks, "are you Hurley? Are you dangerous?" Oh my god: it's Taaaaaaaaaaaaaaaalt (and Gramma)! I have a big stupid smile on my face during their reunion, but it fades when I think of poor Walt, waiting for a visit that never came. Well, except for one mysterious guy named Bentham. Walt doesn't understand the lying. "We're lying... because it's the only way to protect everyone that didn't come back," says Hurley. Really?
- My FREAKED OUT physicist is desperate to get Red off the island: but she's been here before, and isn't ready to leave. At least that's what the Ghostbuster implies through his bitterly clenched teeth. It must have hurt him deeply when Rose scolded him for eating nuts. She stays, it's sad, blah blah blah. These characters had so much potential: will it ever be realized?
- The reunion at THE CHOPPA provides one of Sawyer's best nicknames yet: Kenny Rogers! I could do without the mopey face from him when Kate touches Jack oh-so-tenderly, though. And the survivors take off, and the view of the island is beautiful, and I am sure a few men are happy about the unnecessary Kate cleavage. Wolf Rogers starts to panic when THE CHOPPA has a fuel leak. It could stand to be a few hundred pounds lighter. I can see what's coming... someone's going overboard... and it's probably the one who wasn't among the Oceanic 6. Goodbye, Sawyer. What did you tell Kate to do?
- Assassin Sayid shoots a guy at 8:50, and then sneaks into Hurley's room, where he's playing chess alone. Sayid wants to whisk Hurley away now that the mysterious Bentham is dead. "They said it was suicide." Yeah, I'll bet it was. Sayid stops Hurley from telling us who Bentham really is, and before they leave, Hurley checkmates... Mr. EKO?!? I gasped out loud. Could he come back? Oh god, I hope so.
- Evil Army Guy is still bleeding out, and he gurgles to Ben that Widmore will find him. Then he dies, which means our freighter friends are f*cked. Naturally, THE CHOPPA returns at the worst possible time. There is frenzy and panic, and Sun and baybee make it onboard while they refuel. Jin and Michael are working hard, but Michael dismisses Jin from boom duty by saying "you are a father now," and I get a lump in my throat. Kate wants to get Jin. Jack says no. THE CHOPPA takes off. Jin bursts onto the deck, but it's too late. Below deck, none other than Christian Shepard tells Michael that he "can go now" just as the freighter explodes. Sun screams and screams and screams, and I get one little tear in my left eye. Jack left him behind. What a sh*tty selfish terrible excuse for a leader.
- Back at the Orchid: Ben is angrily throwing metal around and acknowledging that his emotions got the best of him. Switches flip and sparks fly. "[Jacob] wants me to suffer the consequences... whoever moves the island can never come back." Ben, cozy in his Dharma parka (Dharka?), passes the mantle of leadership onto Locke and apologizes for making his life miserable. Then he crawls into a rocky tunnel, down a ladder, through some glass, and into a strange and freaky place... with oddly familiar markings on that pillar. After some manuevering and mumbling to Jacob, Ben manages to push a gear that makes THE MOST ANNOYING SOUND OF ALL TIME. Then... the island is gone. GONE.
- This is bad news for THE CHOPPA. Wolf tries his best, but without fuel, it goes down, with a sound that reminds me of the humpback whales from Star Trek IV. Here is another moment that I feared... Desmond. I felt certain that he wouldn't make it, but for once, Jack does something useful and revives him. After everyone calms down, Hurley points out that Locke moved the island, and Jack scoffs, and Hurley points out that... YEAH, he totally did. A small lightbulb, dim, water-logged, flickers over Jack's head, and he realizes that he needs to start the ball rolling on the whole "we need to lie" thing.
- Penny. Desmond. "I love you, Penny, and I'll never leave you again." Very, very dusty in here. Looks like a week is enough time to work out their story... and sail to Membata. Pilot Wolf and Desmond stay with Penny, since it wouldn't do for them to be rescued. "I'll see you in another life, brother," Jack tells Desmond, so they come full circle. Goodbyes all around. And then the haggard Six paddle away and are rescued, and it's a happy ending.
- Naturally, this is a good time to remember that all is not well. Jack pulls up to the Hoffs/Drawlar funeral parlor, and uses the very subtle "brick to the handle" technique to break in. Here lies Bentham. Jack opens the coffin to reveal... OH JESUS CHRIST. *cough cough* *chokes on pineapple salsa* *drinks water* *cough* SERIOUSLY Ben. You scared the sh*t out of me. "Did he tell you I was off the island?" "Yes he did... he told me that after I left the island, some very bad things happened, and he told me that it was my fault for leaving, and he told me that I had to come back." Ben is nonplussed. "The island won't let you come alone." Told ya they were going back. "I mean everyone, Jack." That means... the coffin... Locke. Locke is dead. Oh. Oh no.
- Sawyer survived his jump, and he swims ashore, where he learns that a) Juliet likes to drown her sorrows in rum and b) the freighter done got blowed up. What happened to them when the island moved?
- Future Kate wakes up to a whispery phone call and and a stranger in Aaron's room. She calls him "my son," which Claire probably doesn't appreciate. "Don't you dare bring him back," she warns. All a dream? Doubtful.
- Future Sun meets Mr. Widmore. She is suddenly a supreme badass, and she and Mr. Widmore have "common interests." She looks sick to her stomach when she walks away from him, though. What is she up to?
- What happened to my physicist? To Rose and Bernard?
- How is it that Jack was in danger of bleeding out from his appendectomy stitches, but crashed into the ocean, in a helicopter, and was fine? Ass.
- Terrible things happened on the island. What kind of things??? Guess we'll find out next season. Thanks for reading my recaps.




